insight example 4 1

Should you accept a counteroffer? Five questions to ask before you say yes

So, you’ve handed in your notice and your manager asks what it would take to make you stay. An an instant there’s more money on the table, a promotion to discuss or flexibility that wasn’t available a week ago.

So, should you accept a counteroffer? It can make sense if it fixes the main reason you wanted to leave, you trust your employer to follow through and you’d genuinely choose to stay on the new terms. If the offer leaves the original problem unresolved, picture how you’ll feel once the initial relief has worn off and you’re back into your usual working week.

Here are five very simple questions to help you decide.

1. Why did you start looking in the first place?

Think back to what prompted you to reply to a recruiter, update your CV or start applying. Were you being paid below market? Had you run out of room to progress or were you simply tired of carrying a workload that was supposed to be temporary? If pay genuinely was the main issue and you’d otherwise have been happy to stay, a salary increase may solve it. If you went looking because you wanted broader experience or a different working pattern, ask what the counteroffer actually changes about your day-to-day working life.

A simple test is to finish this sentence: “I’d be happy to stay if…” Then compare what you’ve written with what’s on the table.

2. What exactly is your employer offering?

“We see you as a future leader” is encouraging. An agreed promotion with a start date, new responsibilities and a revised salary gives you something concrete to weigh up but always ask for the revised terms in writing before you make your decision. If there’s a pay rise, check when it takes effect and whether it’s an increase in base salary or a one-off payment. If the offer includes hybrid working, establish what that means in a typical week and whether the change depends on someone else’s approval, find out who needs to sign it off and when.

The more important the promise is to your decision, the more specific you need it to be.

3. What has changed that makes the offer possible now?

Your resignation may have prompted a decision that had been stuck in a budget or approval process and it is possible that your manager may also have underestimated how much the issue mattered to you. Ask what’s changed and listen to the answer.

This is especially important when the offer involves progression. If you’re being promised a bigger role, where does the extra responsibility come from and who will take on your current work? If a workload problem is going to be solved by hiring another person, has that hire been approved?

Those details help you judge whether there’s a plan your employer can deliver.

4. Which job would you choose if both offers arrived today?

Put the two offers side by side.  Be honest and give the most weight to the things that made you consider moving in the first place. For example, imagine you’re a Financial Controller who wants more exposure to commercial decisions. Your current employer offers a pay rise and a new title. The new role pays a little less but gives you direct responsibility for planning and regular access to the senior leadership team. If commercial experience is what you want, find out how much of it each role actually gives you.

Familiarity has real value. So does the chance to do work you’ve been trying to get closer to. Give both a fair hearing.

5. How will you feel about staying in six months?

Picture an ordinary Tuesday six months from now. You’re back in the same team, the resignation conversation is long behind you and the terms of the counteroffer have kicked in. What’s different about your working day? Would you still be glad you stayed?

It’s also worth asking your manager what they’d expect from you after accepting. If the counteroffer comes with more responsibility, agree what success looks like and when you’ll review how it’s going.

You can be grateful for the offer and still want to move. Equally, if it addresses the issue that made you look elsewhere and you’re genuinely keen to stay, that’s a valid career decision.

Give yourself time to compare both roles, then base your answer on the job you’ll be doing once the negotiations are over.

There are more questions than answers in this article, but it is the scrutiny you give to the answers that will, ultimately, help you make the right decision.

If you’re weighing up a counteroffer and want a recruiter’s perspective on how the two opportunities compare, speak to the team at Meraki Talent.

Related articles

Submit a Job Submit a CV

Submit a CV

Take your next career step.

Thanks for your interest.  We'll be in touch shortly.

Upload

Submit a job

Let us find your next hire.

Thanks for your interest.  We'll be in touch shortly.

Upload